How to Use Shopify Compare at Price to Build Trust and Skyrocket Sales

You’ve seen it a thousand times. You land on a product page for a new jacket. The price is $75. Not bad. But on another site, you see the same jacket presented differently: Price: $75 - Original Price: $125.

Suddenly, that jacket isn't just a jacket. It's a "steal". It's a smart decision. You feel a small jolt of adrenaline, a sense of winning. That, right there, is the psychological power of the Shopify Compare at Price feature.

Welcome to one of the most powerful, and most dangerously misused, tools in your Shopify arsenal.

For e-commerce merchants in the United States, that little "slashed" price is not just a formatting option; it's a powerful psychological trigger. It’s a double-edged sword: used correctly, it creates immense perceived value, builds urgency, and can dramatically increase your conversion rates. Used incorrectly, it can destroy your brand's credibility, make you look cheap, and actually repel savvy modern customers.

This is not another basic "how-to" guide. This is a 2025 deep-dive into the strategy and psychology of the Shopify Compare at Price feature. We'll explore the cognitive biases that make it work, tell the tale of two merchants who used it with VASTLY different results, and give you a practical playbook for using it to build trust and genuinely increase your sales.

What Is the Shopify Compare at Price? A Technical vs. Psychological View

Before we can wield this tool, we must understand what it is. On the surface, the technical definition is simple. But beneath the surface, the psychological definition is where the real power lies.

The Technical Definition

The Shopify Compare at Price is a native field within your Shopify product admin. When you enter a price in this field that is higher than your actual "Price" field, Shopify's themes are coded to display the Compare at price (usually crossed out) next to your lower, active price.

- Price Field: What the customer actually pays. (e.g., $75)

- Compare at price Field: What you're saying the product used to cost. (e.g., $125)

The result on your storefront is that magic, conversion-driving visual: $75 ~~$125~~

The Psychological Definition

This is where it gets interesting. The Shopify Compare at Price feature is a direct line into your customer's brain. It’s a tool for creating a price anchor.

In behavioral economics, "anchoring bias" is a cognitive trigger where people over-rely on the first piece of information they receive (the "anchor") when making a decision.

The $125 is the anchor. It’s not the real price; it's the reference point. Once your customer's brain sees $125, the $75 price tag is no longer just $75. It's now $50 off. It's a 40% discount. It's a "smart deal." You haven't changed the product's value, but you have fundamentally changed its perceived value. This is the entire secret behind the Shopify Compare at Price feature.

The Tale of Two Stores: A Case Study in Trust

The power of the Shopify Compare at Price is directly tied to your brand's integrity. To illustrate this, let's tell the story of two new store owners, Mark and Sarah, who both use this exact same feature.

Mark's "Perpetual Sale" Store (And Why It Failed)

Mark launches "GadgetWorld," a generic dropshipping store. He reads a blog post about the Shopify Compare at Price feature and decides to go all-in. He finds a smart watch he can sell for $50. To make it seem like an incredible deal, he sets the Compare at price to $199.99.

He does this for every single product in his store. His homepage is a sea of red slashes and "75% OFF!" banners. His store is on a permanent, site-wide "sale."

The Result:

For the first week, sales are decent. But soon, things turn.

1. Customers Get Skeptical: Savvy US shoppers, bombarded with fake sales, become suspicious. A "sale" on every item, every day, isn't a sale—it's just the price.

2. Trust Evaporates: Customers use browser extensions like Honey and see the price history. They see the item is never sold at $199.99. They feel deceived.

3. Brand Value Plummets: Mark's brand becomes associated with "cheap," "scammy," and "deceptive." He's now competing with low-quality marketplaces, not legitimate brands. He is forced to constantly run ads because he has zero repeat customers. His use of the Shopify Compare at Price has destroyed his brand equity.

Sarah's "Strategic Event" Boutique (And Why It Succeeded)

Sarah launches "Artisan Home," a curated boutique for high-quality home goods. For the first four months of the year, she never has a sale. Her products are sold at a fair, full price. Her customers learn that her brand stands for quality and value at its given price.

Then, for Black Friday, she plans her first-ever sales event. She selects 10 products for the sale. A popular blanket that has been selling for $100 all year is put on sale for $75.

She goes into her admin and sets:

- Price: $75

- Compare at price: $100

The Result:

1. Genuine Urgency: She sends an email to her list: "Our first-ever Black Friday event is here." Her customers know this is not a drill. The sale is real, and it's for a limited time.

2. A "Smart Deal": The customer's brain sees the $100—the price they remember seeing last month—and validates the $75 as a true, bona fide deal.

3. Trust is Reinforced: Sarah wasn't trying to trick them. She was genuinely rewarding them for their loyalty. The Shopify Compare at Price feature felt honest and exciting.

4. Sales Explode: She sells more in four days than she did in the previous two months. More importantly, she does it while strengthening her brand's reputation for quality and integrity.

The lesson is simple: The Shopify Compare at Price feature is a tool to communicate genuine value. When you invent a fake anchor, you lose all credibility.

The Data: Why Price Anchoring Is a Conversion-Driving Machine

The difference between Mark and Sarah isn't just anecdotal; it's backed by decades of consumer psychology and e-commerce data. Your brain is wired to look for a "deal" because it's a low-effort way to make a smart decision.

Let's look at the psychological triggers at play when you correctly use the Shopify Compare at Price field.

‍

As William Poundstone, author of Priceless, notes, "Price is the most powerful piece of information a customer has... People are not good at judging absolute value. We are good at judging relative value." The Shopify Compare at Price feature gives you the power to frame that relative value in your favor.

Your Practical Playbook: How to Use Shopify Compare at Price (The Right Way)

You're convinced. You want to be like Sarah, not Mark. How do you actually implement this feature technically and, more importantly, strategically?

The "How-To": Setting It Up in Your Shopify Admin (For Beginners)

Let's start with the easy part. Adding a Shopify Compare at Price is incredibly simple.

For a Single Product (with no variants):

1. From your Shopify Admin, go to Products.

2. Click on the product you want to put on sale.

3. Scroll down to the Pricing section.

4. Enter the sale price (what the customer will pay) in the Price field.

4. Enter the original, higher price in the Compare at price field.

5. Click Save.

That's it. Your theme will now automatically show the "slashed" price.

Pro-Tip: You can use Shopify's Bulk Editor to edit the Shopify Compare at Price for many products or variants at once, which is a lifesaver for running a site-wide sale.

Using Compare at Price in Catalogs

When you go to Markets and select a specific catalog, you are given a pricing catalog for specific products have been added. The game-changing feature is your ability to set a market-specific "Compare at price" right next to your market-specific price.

Here is the guide to set up: 

- Product: "New Gene" Dumbo Red Dragon RIBBON BDS Halfmoon Guppy

- Default Price (in your main store): Let's assume it's $25.00.

- Price: You've set a specific price of $20.00.

- Compare at price: You have set this to $25.00.

The Strategic Power of Market-Specific Price Anchoring

This unlocks two core strategies that were previously impossible without complex workarounds:

1. Run Localized Sales & Promotions: This is the most powerful use case. You can now run a "4th of July Sale" specifically for your US customers, showing a Compare at price only for them. Your customers in Canada or the UK will see your normal, full-priced items. This allows you to create targeted sales events that align with local holidays and customer expectations in each market.

2. Set Region-Specific MSRP/RRP: The "Manufacturer's Suggested Retail Price" (MSRP) or "Recommended Retail Price" (RRP) for a product is often different from country to country. This feature allows you to set the correct, legally compliant, and trustworthy Compare at price for each individual market. For your US customers, you can anchor to the USD MSRP, and for your Canadian customers, you can anchor to the CAD MSRP, building trust and transparency globally.

The Strategic Best Practices for 2025 (The Pro-Level)

Setting up the Shopify Compare at Price is easy. Using it to build a lasting brand is an art.

1. Rule #1: Be Honest. Be Legitimate.

2. This is the most important rule. The Compare at price should be a bona fide (genuine) price that the item was sold at for a reasonable period. Do not invent a fantasy price. Your customers are smart, and the internet has a long memory. The fastest way to lose trust is to be caught in a pricing lie.

3. Rule #2: Don't Run a Perpetual Sale.The Shopify Compare at Price feature loses all its power when it's always active. Scarcity and urgency are its fuel. When a sale is "always on," it is, by definition, not a sale. It's just a deceptive price. Use this feature for defined, short-term events:

- Black Friday / Cyber Monday (BFCM)

- End-of-season clearance

- Holiday or anniversary events

- Flash sales (24-48 hours)

4. Rule #3: Do the Math for Your Customer.Don't just show $75 ~~$100~~. That's good, but it's not great. It forces the customer to do mental math. A better approach is to customize your theme (or use a simple app) to add a dynamic "savings badge" next to the price.

- "Save $25!"

- "Save 25%!"

- This simple visual cue reinforces the value of the deal and removes all cognitive friction. It's a key part of an effective Shopify Compare at Price strategy.

5. Rule #4: Combine with Other Urgency Triggers.The Shopify Compare at Price feature works best when it's part of a larger "urgency stack." On your product page, combine your sale price with:

- A Countdown Timer: "Sale ends in 24:10:32"

- A Stock Scarcity Bar: "Only 7 left in stock!"

- A Specific Callout: "BFCM Special - Sale ends Monday!"

- This combination creates an overwhelming psychological pull to complete the purchase immediately.

The Legal & Ethical Tightrope: A Quick Warning

Using the Shopify Compare at Price feature isn't just a branding decision; it's a legal one. The Federal Trade Commission (FTC) has explicit guidelines on deceptive pricing.

In short, the FTC states that a "former" price must be a real, legitimate price at which the product was openly offered for a "substantial period of time." You cannot invent a high "anchor price" just to make your sale look better. This is not just bad strategy; it's illegal.

This is why our strategic advice aligns perfectly with the legal requirements: Use the Shopify Compare at Price honestly. Your brand's reputation is your single most valuable asset. Protect it at all costs.

Conclusion: The Price Is Right, If You Frame It Right

The humble Shopify Compare at Price field is one of the most powerful conversion tools at your disposal. It’s a direct-line to the part of your customer's brain that is hunting for value and looking for a reason to buy now.

But it’s a tool that demands respect.

You have a choice. You can be like Mark, using it as a cheap trick to create a constant, inauthentic "sale" that ultimately erodes all customer trust. Or you can be like Sarah, using it as a strategic, honest tool to communicate genuine value during special events, building excitement and reinforcing brand loyalty.

Go look at your Shopify store right now. How are you using the Shopify Compare at Price? Is it signaling a "smart deal" or a "scammy deal"? Are you building long-term trust or just chasing a short-term sale?

Your customers are smart. Treat them that way. Use the Shopify Compare at Price feature with integrity, and it will become one of the most reliable drivers of profit and loyalty in your entire e-commerce playbook.

‍